[RickinMA]

your current irons may be too light for you to hit consistenty. If you were hitting the less forgiving, light-weight (but heavier than graphite) steel shafted Ping well, you might want to try another steel shaft to see how you do.

I'm surprised to hear you were hitting graphite shafts from 10 years ago more consistent than your current sticks - again, I have to imagine it has something to do with weight and perhaps you would benefit from a heavier club?

I'm also more of a "sweeper" than a "digger", so I don't usually like wide soled clubs.

Keep us posted on what you try and your results