Let's take every top quarterback "but in their PRIME" and I'll pick Favre. Why do you think he retired? He was freezing his buns off when he threw that pic. He's an old man now. He can't play in the cold anymore and if you play in GB it's going to get cold. Favre "in his prime" was the best ever and that includes Peyton and Brady. Favre carried the Packers. They had nothing else. Brady has so much time to throw any good QB could find a receiver.
You guys and the press are sitting back judging the old Favre, not the ONLY 3-time (in a row) MVP.
ONLY 3-time MVP.