If the Arizona Cardinals

[LyleG]

blow this does Kurt still get in the hall?

[Rockford35]

Originally Posted by LyleG

blow this does Kurt still get in the hall?

Not unless he plays D.

R35

[JEFF4i]

Should he? I'd say...yes.

[xamilo]

Well, he is a Superbowl champ, and is leading a team which no one thought would do better than a 5w10L to its first franchise Superbowl. If he wins the SB he should be walking down the hall. If he doesn't he should be in my opinion but most would disagree though.

[mont86]

I don't think so.

[goatster]

since he has one already under his belt.now taking this team there no matter win or lose i think he should be in.

nobody thought the greatest show on turf would win it all because generaly defense wins championships.

[ezra76]

I think he'll need this Superbowl and the Superbowl MVP. His career #'s are very weak. 182TD's and 28K yards passing. Farve has 464/65K.

[MGP]

2 ways to get into the hall of fame -- monster numbers or more than one championship (wins).

Marino got in via the 1st route, several others via the 2nd.

I think if the Cards win, Warner has a good shot. Otherwise, not so good.

[BigJim13]

Originally Posted by ezra76

I think he'll need this Superbowl and the Superbowl MVP. His career #'s are very weak. 182TD's and 28K yards passing. Farve has 464/65K.

He also has the same # of SB appearance and WINS as Favre right now, with this upcoming SB he will have MORE SB appearances. I say he was already in once the Cards got to the NFC Championship game.

***on a side note, how many interceptions did Favre throw? Not trying to cause a stir here, I always thought Favre was overrated***

****On another side note, I am biased about Favre as I am a die hard 49ers fan and he killed us several times****

[ezra76]

The only reason I use Farve as example is because they will end up being voted on in the same year. If it's one or the other, Farve has him by 10 miles as far as HOF #'s are considered.

Edit- I'm talking out my a$$ again. Took a few minutes to look at the HOF website. He's a lock, regardless. His #'s are better than Terry Bradshaw's.

[chemboy2]

Originally Posted by BigJim13

He also has the same # of SB appearance and WINS as Favre right now, with this upcoming SB he will have MORE SB appearances. I say he was already in once the Cards got to the NFC Championship game.

***on a side note, how many interceptions did Favre throw? Not trying to cause a stir here, I always thought Favre was overrated***

****On another side note, I am biased about Favre as I am a die hard 49ers fan and he killed us several times****

I would say getting them to the SB and not just the NFC title game is what will put him over the top. Now, if the Cards win, then I don't think there is even a doubt he gets in; especially considering they're playing the Steelers.

[indacup]

Certainly should,

Only Tom Brady has been in more Super Bowls in the same time frame....he's ranked 3rd in passing percentage....seems he should be a shoo in.