Best QB Ever!?

[BigJim13]

Just like the title says, what do you think?

It can be anybody past or present as long as you can back it up with why you picked him! I will start:

Joe Montana: 4 SB rings, 3 SB MVP's, basically helped Bill Walsh implement the West Coast offense in the NFL. He was magic to watch to!

 

[azgreg]

Ryan Leaf.

 

[Dogfish Head]

I think talent wise Peyton Manning. Best QB wrapped around best team? Tom Brady, as much as I hate to say it.

 

[limpalong]

Read an article in Sports Illustrated some years ago about Unitas and the Baltimore Colts. Those guys all had to have jobs to support families, since playing pro football didn't pay well. Unitas and his team mates would rent apartments for their families and do fixer-upper work to pay the rent. They would play a pro football game and, after the game, still need to get together to paint or install carpet, etc. After reading that article, came away with quite an appreciation for those who played simply out of a love for the game. Some of those "yesterday" quarterbacks... Unitas, Tarkenton, Y.A. Tittle, etc. cannot be judged against the coddled millionaires of today's game.

 

[braveheart]

What a game today? Patriots season ticket holder here enjoying another playoff game.
Joe Montana. Tom Brady is a close second.

 

[nututhugame]

What a game today? Patriots season ticket holder here enjoying another playoff game.
Joe Montana. Tom Brady is a close second.

I can pretty much agree with this. Peyton Manning has to be in the conversation. A damn shame Marino never won a ring because he would be too. The book is far from written on Aaron Rodgers.

 

[xamilo]

Ryan Leaf.

Are you retarded? Jamarcus Russell eats Ryan Leaf for Breakfast!!!!

 

[SplooGe]

Are you retarded? Jamarcus Russell eats Ryan Leaf for Breakfast!!!!

But Russell was on the "purple drank", the PED of all PED's.

 

[MCDavis]

Can't leave out Bob Griese (I'm not a Dolphins fan, btw). He is the only QB with a true undefeated, untied season. He was amazing to watch play the game.

 

[Dogfish Head]

Ugh, screw Shula.

 

[azgreg]

I've thought about it for a while now and I've come to the conclusion......Tony Eason.

 

[xamilo]

How about Trent Dilffer? He's got more SB rings than Marino, and just as many as Drew Brees and Peyton Manning heheheehhe