How's this shaft extractor?

[BigJim13]

I was thinking about picking up a shaft extractor and was looking at this one for my garage workshop. Any thoughts on this one or is there another one I should check out? Thanks All!

CLUBMAKERS VISE SHAFT EXTRACTOR

 

[LyleG]

Its not very good at all. I know 2 people that had them and they were nothing but trouble.
I prefer the golfsmith stuff for tools. This is the shaft extractor I use. I have pulled hundreds of shafts with it and have never had a problem. Well worth the extra hundred bucks imo.

Golfsmith.com: Clubmaker Shaft Extractor - Clubmaker

 

[gunning4u]

For a 180$ look at the Jb Jr extractor. Lyle is it any good?

YouTube - JB's Junior Hydraulic Golf Shaft Extractor

 

[Clugnut]

It is good. I have that model, works beautifully.

 

[BigJim13]

It is good. I have that model, works beautifully.

Which one, the one I put a link to, Lyles or the other one? LOL

 

[Clugnut]

Which one, the one I put a link to, Lyles or the other one? LOL

Yeah, the JB. I'm holding my sleeping daughter and typing with one hand. PIA

 

[LyleG]

The Golfsmith one is better than the JB one. I have used both and am staying with the GS model.

 

[BigJim13]

Yeah, the JB. I'm holding my sleeping daughter and typing with one hand. PIA

I know exactly how you feel...LOL

 

[Augster]

That JB Jr. Hydraulic is the only extractor you will need. It is the greatest thing I have ever bought for my shop. You don't need torches with it. A simple heat gun will do.

Hell, I bet you could do head-pulling with a hairdryer with the JB Jr. It's awesome and totally portable. You don't need to put it in a vise. Pulls take mere seconds with it.

You never have to worry about the paint on a clubhead getting too hot because the heat you use is so low because of the hydraulic pressure. The metal isn't even hot to the touch in most cases after a pull. No more having to wear a glove to hold the head after it comes off.

I highly recommend it.

 

[MGP]

I have the Golfworks clubmaker's vise puller. It's only OK, but I already had the clubmakers vise so it seemed to make sense.

I don't pull a lot of shafts but if I start doing more I think I'd get the JB jr. Everyone I know that has them loves it.