dave.
Well-Known Member
- Mar 20, 2005
- 5,926
- 2
I am not convinced by that analysis Benk.Every player comes inside,this move is impossible to avoid because of the right shoulder and right leg.Hogan has some very simple pictures in his book showing this,and he then shows his right elbow tucking tight into his right hip,all golfers require this move regardless of plane.
No offence but this one of the reasons I stopped reading those forums,I just kept to Hogan's book.Imho if you are trying to stop doing this you are in effect doing what King Canute tried to do,stop the inevitable.Every player will drop inside,then come through 'behind and under' as Harvey Penick calls it,and at the same time you hit hard with the body rotation.Hardy says you can do this as hard as you like from the top,that doesn't work for me at all but I am sure it has works for many of his students.
It is physically impossible t o have a 100% 1 plane,ie you go back and down on the same plane.I think you may have misunderstood some part of whatever book you read if you are genuinely trying to do this.Have a look at Hogan's diagrams.
No offence but this one of the reasons I stopped reading those forums,I just kept to Hogan's book.Imho if you are trying to stop doing this you are in effect doing what King Canute tried to do,stop the inevitable.Every player will drop inside,then come through 'behind and under' as Harvey Penick calls it,and at the same time you hit hard with the body rotation.Hardy says you can do this as hard as you like from the top,that doesn't work for me at all but I am sure it has works for many of his students.
It is physically impossible t o have a 100% 1 plane,ie you go back and down on the same plane.I think you may have misunderstood some part of whatever book you read if you are genuinely trying to do this.Have a look at Hogan's diagrams.